Call Me Ishmael

Old Smokey :

You really don't give up, do you?

But then you have so much to lose.

It's what we have in common.

William-as-Mulder :

We have nothing in common.

Old Smokey :

I need The Boy.

The Boy is mine.

William-as-Mulder :

The Boy would rather die first,

now that he knows The Truth.

Old Smokey :

That I'm the one who made him?

That I'm William's creator?

William-as-Mulder :

You'd shoot your own 

firstborn son?

Old Smokey :

Shot my second-born son, once.

But I need you to know, Fox,

when I gave you Life,

I never fathomed the moment would come

when I would need to end it.

William-as-Mulder :

I don't think you can do it.

Old Smokey :

Then you don't know me very well.

He shoots William-as-Mulder in The Head — He falls, backwards into The Water.

Mulder comes out of a side door just in time to see what Old Smokey has done.

Mulder :

Hey!

He shoots Old Smokey — 

6 times, in The Chest,

but not in The Head.

And he PUSHES him into The Water.